Claims

If you need to make a claim, here are the numbers to call.  Find your carrier and their 800 numbers below.

Builder’s Mutual 800-809-4862

Dairyland/Peak Property & Casualty 800-334-0090

Donegal/Southern Insurance 800-877-9006

Firstcomp 888-500-3344

Foremost Star/Business WC Claim 866-967-5256

Foremost Star/Business besides WC 800-435-7764

Foremost Star/Personal Auto 800-274-7865

Foremost Star/Personal besides Auto 800-527-3907

GMAC/National General Agency 800-468-3466

Hagerty 800-922-4050

Metlife Auto & Home 800-854-6011

Progressive 866-621-4823

Universal Property & Casualty 800-470-0599

Utica/Graphic Arts Mutual 800-216-1420

UPC – United Property and Casualty      888-256-3378 or submit a claim online.

Hartford   800-989-7824

Travelers   800-238-6225

Metlife Commercial   855-500-3695

If you need any assistance with facilitating a claim, please contact us for assistance.